The Broad Bench tried to seat a chair of the Lower Gallery by the Binding of Numbers, the tally spell cut into the gallery's floor chalk. Each member inside the ring drops one signed ribbon into a copper bowl. The charm lifts a name only when one pile clears the majority bead. On Thursday night the bead sat at 118. The bowl held 234 ribbons. The highest pile stopped at 96.
Night clerk Bramble Holt ran every pass the same way. Doors barred, names called once, ribbons dropped without speech, the bowl turned three times against the sun, the bead set on the lip until it rings or stays dull. A ring seats a chair. A dull bead sends the ribbons back and leaves the ring shut.
The first three casts returned the ribbons unsorted. Holt logged them as voids. The charm had power. The sort stayed flat. On the fourth cast the sort caught and split the bowl three ways: 96 to Vesper Lund, 91 to Orrin Keel, 47 to Sedge Mallow. The fifth matched the fourth. The sixth matched it until the bead cracked.
The bead is a glass counter blown for the gallery at Celestia University. It opened along a hairline while Holt was writing the sixth total. The canteen under the gallery had closed. The only hard round thing on the clerk's ledge was the lid of a pickle jar, tin, bent at one edge, smelling of dill. Holt set the lid where the bead had sat and turned the bowl a seventh time. The lid stayed dull. The piles held at 96, 91, and 47.
"The lid is doing the job," Holt said. "It counted what the bowl was given. Nopony in that ring has a majority, and another pass will count the same ribbons."
Lund, who brought a weighted variant he calls the clarity pass, said a grant board at the Canterlot Institute had called his method sound. The Institute has yet to run it. The pass would give a second ribbon to any member with more than six years on the bench. Holt left it out. The floor chalk describes one ribbon. A second ribbon is a different spell.
"The next pass will take," Lund said. "The review already signed the method. The room is just tired."
Keel has told the same room that the ribbons are his and the charm is what failed. His count, read from a card he kept against his chest, put him at 121. Holt's bowl has produced no such pile. Mallow has kept her 47. She sleeps inside the ring with the ribbon under one hoof and answers the roll by lifting her chin. On Wednesday she ate the last oat cake on the clerk's tray and set the wrapper back on the tray, squared to the edge.
The Broad Bench entered the week holding enough seats to organize the gallery. Organizing still required a chair. The Far Benches seated theirs by voice vote on Monday and have watched from the upper rows for four nights. None has stepped over the chalk. The Broad Bench barred its own doors at the first cast and has renewed the bar each time the bead stayed dull.
Holt's card is the break log, written in blunt pencil: void, void, void, split, split, split, lid, split, split. He asked Warden Tamsin Reeve, who keeps the doors, for a recess before the seventh so a second clerk could count the ring in daylight. Reeve said the bench had voted to remain. Holt asked who had counted that vote. Reeve said the room had been of one mind.
The Canterlot Institute keeps a clean bowl and a spare bead for seating trials. Holt sent for both at dusk on Tuesday. The crate is still in the institute yard. Lund's office answered that a second workshop would confuse the debut. Keel's office answered that a second workshop would insult the bench. Mallow sent nothing back. She stayed inside the ring.
Reeve posted a tenth cast for dawn. The pickle lid is on the lip of the bowl. The cracked bead is in Holt's coat pocket, two pieces wrapped in the sixth tally. He signed the night as a repeat of that tally, run on tin.
At first light the ring was still shut. The last line on Holt's card, written before he went to wash the dill off his hoof, said the Institute's bowl had stayed in the yard, and that 96, 91, and 47 were the figures on the table.